As president-elect Donald Trump continues to unveil plans for his presidency, many Americans brace themselves for dramatic changes to the educational system. Trump has not held back his criticism of the Department of Education, and instituting the school choice program appears to be high on his list of things to do.
From the beginning of his campaign, Trump has voiced his support for educational reform, suggesting that “failing government schools” have created a trap for underprivileged youths. While it may seem that every new administration brings with them amendments to the educational system, the nationwide implementation of school choice would require a significant overhaul of the nation’s education landscape. The impacts, both positive and negative, are expected to be dramatic.
The Choice of Schools
In theory, school choice offers parents of all socioeconomic statuses the same opportunity to provide their children with the best possible education. This is a step toward educational equality, but it may not be as clear-cut as it seems. Proponents of school choice suggest that this program gives parents complete control over their children’s education and the ability to choose where their educational tax dollars are spent.
However, the program achieves this by taking the tax dollars that have traditionally gone to the public school system and giving them back to the parents. This implies that a significant portion of public school funding will be excised, likely going to school’s in more desirable neighborhoods instead. These changes could severely damage the inner city school system, leaving those who must live and attend school there with no options at all.
Ideally, by giving parents a choice in schools, the school choice programs will create competition among institutions as they vie for the interests of students, incentivizing those institutions and their teachers to provide better instruction and improved programs to attract students and revenues. The institutions that cater best to the needs of the parents and their children will succeed, whereas those institutions that fail to attract students would simply forgo funding and eventually cease to exist.
The detractors of school choice argue that public institutions in undesirable neighborhoods will not have the resources to compete. The associated fears are that school choice will ultimately lead to the depletion of schools in already-disadvantaged neighborhoods. While some students will undoubtedly benefit from the ability to choose and move schools, others will be left behind in the schools with significantly reduced funding.
While the debate of how school choice will impact the American school system, the movement is becoming a reality. Back in September of 2016, Trump voiced his support school choice and promised that he would move to implement it immediately should he be elected. His proposed budget calls for using $20 billion in federal funds, along with $110 billion of collective state funding, to encourage all 50 states to implement school choice. When Trump named Betsy DeVost, a vocal advocate of the educational reform, as his choice for education secretary, the plan for implementing school choice seemed all but cemented.
The Death Knell for Common Core
Consequently, as educators in the United States prepare for school choice, many expect that the Common Core State Standards initiative (CCSS) might be on the way out. Trump has been critical of the Common Core standardized testing in schools, saying that “education has to be run locally.” Moreover, Common Core and the concept of a standardized education is exactly what school choice fights against. Proponents of school choice suggest that the program will provide parents with a diverse array of educational options for their child’s individual needs, discourse that seems to fly in the face of standardized tests. At this point, it seems very unlikely that the two programs, school choice and Common Core, can coexist.
Despite all the positive discussion surrounding school choice regarding freedom, opportunity, and equality, there is a vocal group rallying against school choice, warning that the program might be hiding some negative implications. While school choice advocates suggest that this movement will encourage public institutions to improve the way they do business, public schools in undesirable neighborhoods are lamenting that they do not have the resources to compete.
Additionally, parents in low-income neighborhoods might not have the necessary time or resources to properly investigate what schools are best for their children. Similarly, transportation and extracurricular costs associated with the more desirable schools might exclude students from families in low-income households, which would lead to greater segregation, not the other way around.
Many school choice detractors have spoken up against the ensuing privatization of education, arguing that the movement opens education up to profiteers who not only lack the education and experience to run a school, but allows them to easily exploit an under-regulated environment to maximize their personal profits.
Technology and Distance
As discussed, one of the major potential drawbacks of school choice is that economic and logistical factors might limit the amount of choice some families have. Rather than negate racial and economic segregation in American schools, school choice could, in fact, make it worse. Overcoming some, if not all, of these limitations, however, might be available in the form of educational technology and distance education.
As online programs and eLearning become more readily available, students that are unable to attend the school of their choice because of distance–hindered by the commute or the financial implications of the travel–could find options online. Ideally, this would allow students that would otherwise be forced to study at an undesirable public school nearby to study at any school, regardless of the location. Though this would require a major overhaul of the online educational environment in the U.S., as well as a thorough investigation into the additional costs incurred by each online student, distance education takes steps toward answering some of the primary concerns from critics of school choice.
You May Also Like This
BBnaija: Efe Wins Not By God’s Grace As It Is ‘Immoral’– Evangelist Mike Bamiloye
Founder of Mount Zion Ministries, Evangelist Mike Bamiloye, has cautioned pastors against making reference to ...read more
Read This As Soon As Possible! It Is Being Deleted From Everywhere Because It Is More Efficient Than Any Medicine!
The drink we are presenting you today is one of the most beneficial and effective ...read more
Calling All Educators: What Do You Care About?
Calling on all teachers, administrators, and education specialists! We want to hear from you! To ensure ...read more
Is Technology Holding Students Back?
Is technology a panacea or a plague in the classroom? The honest answer is “neither”, ...read more
Which Learning Style Works For You?
It wouldn’t come as a shock for most teachers to hear that the way students ...read more
I Will Teach Girls How To Prevent Early Pregnancy– Stephanie Okereke-Linus
Multiple award winning Producer and actress, Stephanie Linus-Okereke, has vowed to provide teenage girls with ...read more
Don’t Weep for Public Education Just Yet!
Betsy DeVos’ nomination and confirmation as the Trump administration’s Secretary of Education have been a ...read more
Teaching Students Good Digital Citizenship
Teachers have long understood the importance of instilling good citizenship in their students, focusing on ...read more
RECIPE!! Okra Water Cures Diabetes, Asthma, Cholesterol And Kidney Diseases. Here Is How To Prepare It At Home!!
The name okra is most often used in the UK, United States and the Philippines, ...read more
Primary School Pupils Arrested For Not Doing Their Home Works in Enugu
Sometimes, you just can’t believe what happens in this country. We have seen a lot ...read more
LADIES!!! Watch Natural Ways To Tighten Your Va gina Without Any Surgery Or Drug
How to tighten your vagina: There are many people who believe that it’s possible that, ...read more
Podcasts and the Classroom
Chances are, even if you’ve never listened to a podcast before, you’ve heard about one. ...read more
5 Innovative Mind-Mapping Tools For Education
What do you do when you have an elaborate project, assignment, or paper that needs ...read more
1,000 Education Apps Organized By Subject & Price
Sure, there are plenty of apps you can use in education. There are even apps ...read more
Bringing Art Back With Technology
With continued budget cuts, a greater focus on math and reading education, and an enduring ...read more
The Pros and Cons of Technology
Using technology in the classroom is one of those issues that makes it easy to ...read more
Head of the Class: 2016’s Top Technology
Like your students, educational technology is constantly evolving. The best digital resources–including apps, websites, video, ...read more
President Trump’s Education Agenda
When it comes to education, president-elect Donald Trump divulged few details regarding his plans for ...read more
The One Present I Wish Parents Would Give My Students
The gifts that change your life are the ones you didn’t know you wanted in ...read more
Write Shorter, Simpler Standards
We have too many standards. Many of you will agree, they are too long. In ...read more
How Do We Teach Kids to Use Smartphones Safely?
Most students use smartphones with unfiltered access to the Internet. Even worse, many students have ...read more
Treat People with Dignity and Respect
Someone thought Dad was a poor dirt farmer. Here’s how they tell the story. You ...read more
Cool Cat Teacher’s Gift List 2016 Edition
If you’ve ever struggled to buy presents like I do, you probably ask people what ...read more
How to Assign Homework without Wasting Everybody’s time
If you ever assign homework, you have likely dealt with the “Why does my child ...read more
4 Key Factors for Fantastic Formative Assessment
Too many times the research is completely disconnected from the classroom. But in today’s show, ...read more
How to Understand Cyberbullying: From a Teen’s Experience
When bad things happen – do kids have someone they trust? Are you that someone? ...read more
iBooks 2 and iTunes U: A Quick Review from a Teacher #edapp
The world is buzzing with the Apple announcements about their move into eTextbooks. As I ...read more
5 Essential Effective Blended Learning Best Practices
Online and face-to-face spaces blend to create a today’s classroom. Most schools have physical buildings. For purposes of ...read more
5 Ways to Resolve Social Media Misunderstandings and a conversation with @swpax
Misunderstandings happen. They happen on Twitter. They happen on Facebook. They happen in our lives. CASE ...read more
How Online Learning Works
What is Online Learning? With the use of technology on the rise, online learning continues to ...read more